Support The Saudis

An American University plans an engineer training facility in Saudi Arabia that will admit only men. That’s drawn criticism, but the plan is a net gain for Saudi civil society, and we hope it goes ahead.

The story (free registration required, and hat tip LGF):

If Cal Poly San Luis Obispo had wanted to start an engineering program for a university in someplace like Norway, the proposal probably would have sailed through without much comment either on campus or off.

But the school’s plan to start an engineering department in Saudi Arabia is a different story.

Some staffers and students contend that the university — which prides itself on the number of female engineers it graduates — should steer clear of a kingdom where women’s rights are restricted and a fledgling engineering program would be open only to men…

A critic commented:

“A woman in Saudi Arabia got 200 lashes for being gang-raped,” he said, indignant that his school would consider a venture there. “What is this administration talking about?”

Sentenced for “un-Islamic behavior,” the woman was pardoned last year by King Abdullah after international outrage over the planned flogging. Still, Saudi women require a man’s permission to seek medical care, cannot drive or vote, and must be veiled in public.

Not to mention the Saudi court that just condemned a woman to death for witchcraft, putting that nation 292 years behind the UK.

But the Saudi plan is a step forward for women:

Over five years, Cal Poly would receive $5.9 million from the Saudi government to create an engineering curriculum, build labs and train teachers in Jubail, a sprawling oil center on the Persian Gulf. Only men would qualify to take or teach engineering classes, although the campus has separate classes in other disciplines for women.

But in our countries prior to WW2, engineering courses admitted only men.

And long after WW2 women engineers were a rarity – Mrs G was the first woman to graduate from her university with an electronics degree. And when she started work as the first female programmer and insisted on wearing pants suits, management had to grant her a special exception to their general rule that women (until then all secretarial staff) wear skirts or dresses.

So insisting Saudis immediately adopt our gender-neutrality is hypocritical, given the centuries it took us to achieve social consensus on this matter.

And it’s daft to criticize Islamic nations for their backwardness while denigrating their attempts – as with this project – to modernize their economies and societies.

If we don’t plan on perpetual war with Muslim nations, we should support them, warts and all, as they modernize at their own pace and by their own efforts.

Advertisements

4 Responses to Support The Saudis

  1. dearieme says:

    I remember, in the 60s, a rather glamorous, sophisticated Iranian girl who was the sole female reading Chemical Engineering. Someone asked her “How will you get a job?” She said that if all else failed she could always run Daddy’s refinery.

  2. gandalf says:

    dearieme

    And you let her get away? Shame on you!

  3. You should identify yourself, rather than being nameless…. be brave little blogger.

    Well, American Universities have had a horrible history staying involved with governments-with-issues long after their true nature was known. There were American Universities working with Nazi Germany with many of the same rationalizations you are providing up to the second world war.

    I am reminded that Osama Bin Laden went to the UK for his education… didn’t do much to change his mind on things.

    I feel very sorry for England and their challenges… and helping the Saudis wouldn’t help.

  4. gandalf says:

    roger freeberg

    The history you refer to is the junk science of eugenics – the early 20th century equivalent of AGW. It did indeed obsess American and British academia and was used by Hitler to justify genocide.

    But this post is about a Californian university helping the Saudis set up an engineering faculty, which is not not junk science.

    It’s important the Islamic world modernizes and joins us in the sun.

    For us to treat Muslims as Nazis and equate engineering to the junk science of eugenics seems unlikely to achieve that.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: